Growing up I was really only aware of one kind of preaching and that was pentecostal preaching. This was how I thought preaching ought to be done. It was my only model. My childhood pastor's name was Brother J.D. Hurt and for the most part he was spontaneous and at times electrifying. Then I would listen to the likes of Kenneth Hagin, T.L. Osborn, Kathryn Kuhlman, and copious amounts of Kenneth Copeland. I went to Casey Treat's church for a stint. I enjoyed the preaching of men like Dutch Sheets and Carlton Pearson. And I salivated over the bombastic fare of T.D. Jakes. Each of these had their own distinct personality, yet all seemed to possess the pentecostal aura. These were the men and women who shaped and cast my imagination of preaching.
If I could give it a name, I'd call it...
The Pentecostal School of Preaching
Then in 1998 I became aware of a distinctly different realm of preaching. I loved the worship music disc called Passion '98. It had songs like "Better is One Day" and "We Fall Down." I probably burned that disc to my psyche, ten times over. I absolutely loved, well... the driving passion behind it. Then, I started hearing about the Passion Worship Conferences and would listen to some of their speakers. I quickly discerned they were cut from a different cloth. I listened to guys like Louie Giglio and John Piper for the first time and really appreciated what they were doing. They seemed to choose one main text for their sermons, instead of resorting to many small ones throughout. Then since coming to seminary I've been more fully acquainted with others in their camp. Men like Tim Keller, Mark Dever, Al Mohler, Bryan Chapell are the main proponents and avow a high regard for a Calvinistic world view. All have their own personalities but all share many common distinctives.
This I would call...
The Reformed School of Preaching
And then if that weren't enough, just this year, I stumbled upon yet another major camp of preachers! I guess you can call them the Mainliners. I discovered these guys through the writings of Will Willimon. This guy loves preaching and has some excellent things to say about it. So to get a flavor for how he preached I did some snooping around on Youtube, Amazon, and looked up some of the citations from Willimon's books to discover the major voices in these pulpits. I listened to preachers like Henry Craddock, Walter Brueggemann, Thomas G. Long, and Barbara Brown Taylor and read their views and I asked myself, "does the learning never end?" As I viewed their preaching I was struck with a different sense. Their sermons weren't long; I'd actually call them homilies. They were heavily story driven, thought provoking, and certainly had their own vernacular.
And I'd call this...
The Mainline School of Preaching (Possibly even the Narrative School).
And the following have been some of my general observations of these somewhat distinct schools. I find the distinctions fascinating and even instructive. And again, these are just generalizations. Many preachers represented in each 'school' can be the exception and have their own style.
Common Approach:
Pentecostal: Spirit-led
Reformed: Expository
Mainline: Narrative
Valued Feature:
Pentecostal: Anointed
Reformed: Well-prepared
Mainline: Applicable
Prevailing Theme:
Pentecostal: The Presence of God
Reformed: The Glory of God
Mainline: The Justice of God
Driving Motivation:
Pentecostal: Revival
Reformed: Reformation
Mainline:
Liberal - Morality /
Neo-Orthodox - Imagination
Social Constituency:
Pentecostal: Mid to Lower Class
Reformed: Middle Class
Mainline: Mid to Upper Class
Ethnic Constituency:
Pentecostal: Interracial
Reformed: Strongly Caucasian
Mainline: Predominately Caucasian
Desired Outcome:
Pentecostal: Altar Call Ministry
Reformed: Teaching
Mainline: Sacrament
Typical Length:
Pentecostal: 30-40 minutes (up to 60 if things are really cranking).
Reformed: 50-60 minutes
Mainline: 20 minutes
Features I personally appreciate and deem worth emulating from each school:
Pentecostal: Obviously, I'm of a Pentecostal persuasion, so I resonate most with the core theology. Love the power and urgency of Pentecostal Preaching. Love the willingness to flow with the Spirit.
Reformed: Love the erudition of Reformed pulpits. They love theology and history. And I LOVE expository preaching!
Mainline: These are typically highly literate people. I love their regard for words and their use of stories. Jesus came a tellin' stories and they do it better than any school around.
I'll add more as I think of them... and please share any that I've left off.